BlogAds

Show Me Progress blog advertising is good for you

Blogads

In KC? Join us for libations every Wednesday!
Drinking Liberally - Midtown KC

Vulcan's Forge:

The Midwest's Premiere Sterling Silver Jewelers
Vulcans Forge

Located in the heart of Westport -- The Original Kansas City

Californos Californo's: Elegant dining in a delightful atmosphere, located in the heart of Westport
Search




Advanced Search
Local / Regional Links
National Links

Missouri news, views, and issues - Show Me Progress

President Obama on Melanie Shouse: "How can I say to her, 'You know what? We're giving up'"?

  

by: Michael Bersin

Thu Feb 04, 2010 at 20:40:21 PM CST


Previously:

Late healthcare activist Melanie Shouse tells her story

Death of an activist

We just received the following transcript (excerpted):

THE WHITE HOUSE

Office of the Press Secretary

__________________________________________________________________________________

For Immediate Release                                             February 4, 2010

REMARKS BY THE PRESIDENT
AND Q&A
AT DEMOCRATIC NATIONAL COMMITTEE
FUNDRAISING RECEPTION

Capital Hilton
Washington, D.C.

6:15 P.M. EST

THE PRESIDENT: ....And, yes, we are going to keep fighting to fix a health system that too often works better for the insurance industry than it does for the American people.  (Applause.)  Now, I -- you heard me at the State of the Union -- I didn't take this on because it was good politics.  I love how the pundits on these cable shows, they all announce, "Oh, boy, this was really tough politically for the President."  Well, I've got my own pollsters, I know -- (laughter) -- I knew this was hard.  I knew seven Presidents had failed.  I knew seven Congresses hadn't gotten it done.  You don't think I got warnings, "Don't try to take this on"?  I got those back in December of last year.

So, yes, we knew this was hard.  But I took it on because families were at the mercy of skyrocketing premiums, soaring out-of-pocket costs, insurance companies that routinely deny coverage because of preexisting conditions, or see their insurance dropped altogether because they get sick.

We took it on because costs were closing small businesses.  They were keeping larger ones from competing on a level playing field.  They were eating into workers' take-home pay.  They were canceling raises.  We took it on because it's the single best way to bring down our deficits.  (Applause.)  By the way, nobody has disputed that.  When I was before the Republican caucus, it was very clear.  I said, look, you say you're concerned about deficit reduction?  Nobody can dispute the fact that if we don't tackle surging health care costs, that we can't get control of our budget.  And by the way, the approach that we put forward would reduce our deficit by as much as a trillion dollars over the next two decades.

We took it on because every single day, 15,000 Americans join the tens of millions who don't have health insurance -- and every single year, 18,000 Americans die because of it.

I got a letter -- I got a note today from one of my staff -- they forwarded it to me -- from a woman in St. Louis who had been part of our campaign, very active, who had passed away from breast cancer.  She didn't have insurance.  She couldn't afford it, so she had put off having the kind of exams that she needed.  And she had fought a tough battle for four years.  All through the campaign she was fighting it, but finally she succumbed to it.  And she insisted she's going to be buried in an Obama t-shirt.  (Laughter.)

But think about this:  She was fighting that whole time not just to get me elected, not even to get herself health insurance, but because she understood that there were others coming behind her who were going to find themselves in the same situation and she didn't want somebody else going through that same thing.  (Applause.)  How can I say to her, "You know what?  We're giving up"?  How can I say to her family, "This is too hard"?  How can Democrats on the Hill say, "This is politically too risky"?  How can Republicans on the Hill say, "We're better off just blocking anything from happening"?

That can't be the message that the American people are delivering.  Yes, they're nervous, they're anxious, they're in a tough time right now.  The thing they want most are jobs.  They really don't like the process in Washington, the sausage-making.  That part I understand.  But I know that they don't -- but I know they don't want to just offer nothing to the millions of people in America who are in the situation that that woman was in.  That's what we campaigned on.  And we are going to keep on working to get it done -- with Democrats and I hope with Republicans and everybody else in between -- to bring down costs, to end the worst practices of the insurance industry, to finally give every American the chance to choose quality, affordable health care.  We are going to keep on working to get it done.  (Applause.)

AUDIENCE:  Yes we can!  Yes we can!  Yes we can!

THE PRESIDENT:  I am not going to walk away from these fights.  And I know you won't -- because you didn't before.  You didn't when folks were slamming doors in your faces -- "Barama who?"  (Laughter.)  You didn't quit when you heard voices saying we should scale back and throttle down and accept less.  You remember that.  When folks were saying our sights were set too high; that our faith in this country was misplaced; that our hope was naïve; that you couldn't change Washington; that you had to accommodate yourself to the political realities.  You've all heard that.  You didn't listen to those voices then -- your voice proved them wrong.  You proved that nothing can withstand the power of millions of voices that are calling for change....

[emphasis added]
Michael Bersin :: President Obama on Melanie Shouse: "How can I say to her, 'You know what? We're giving up'"?
Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email





Melanie and the President (0.00 / 0)
I'm sure there were many others besides myself who wrote to the White House about Melanie.  I'm so glad President Obama told her story, even if not by name, to the Democrats who gathered with him today.  I suggested flowers from the White House would be a nice gesture.  We'll see.

It is unconscionable that those who claim to "represent" us enjoy excellent, easily accessed health care while heroic Americans like Melanie are allowed to die because of the poltical "risk" Blue Dogs like Claire McCaskill are afraid to take.  If the members of Congress had half the courage and integrity that Melanie had, we wouldn't even be having this conversation in 2010.   Shame on them.  

Health Care for America Now leaders are calling for rallies on February 17 - three days after Melanie's memorial service.  How many more Melanies must die before we get the attention of our "leaders"?


When LaDonna told me the news... (0.00 / 0)
I immediately shared it with several in our Democratic community including hotflash -- it is heartening to hear what Barack is saying. This is what I wrote, maybe our messages sharing Melanie's story actually were heard -- taking care of folks is the moral high ground, it's refreshing to see that high ground start to be defended with a little dignity and pride, instead of being toppled off-balance talking about how "there really aren't any death panels"...

Jan 30th
Subject: I don't know if you heard yet

But Melanie Shouse, a local stalwart activist for social justice and single payer health care passed on very recently.

I heard the news from LaDonna Appelbaum - to refresh your memory,  she read a powerful statement at the health care rally in front of Lacy Clay's office and gave a testimony alongside Rebecca Tobias in front of  Anthem in downtown St. Louis.

Melanie was attempting to get treatment out of state as she was denied care by her health insurance.  Her illness could have been treated -- 45,000 people die each year due to lack of access to care.

It's unbelievable the Republicans have been so callous to the suffering of dear members our American family.  

As I've written in the past, can you imagine an initiative that could actually stop all violent murders in a year? Or stop all deaths due to drunk driving? Miraculous, right? Well, getting everyone access to care could save as many lives as these fantasy scenarios, and yet the status quo is preferable to the Republicans who blocked reform. This political tragedy perpetuates a swath of carnage in its wake. It's time for Democrats to expose the real personal stories of people like Melanie to marshal the anger and righteous indignation caused by great moral injustice - the tea party townhalls monopolized the anger on the other side and our leadership was left dissembling. Can you imagine if Obama went on a townhall tour and in each city interviewed families who have lost loved ones due to our broken and inhumane health care system? - let stories like Melanie's ring out? LaDonna told me Melanie wanted to be cremated with her Obama t-shirt on.

Godspeed Melanie Shouse you were an inspiration to us all.

We will miss you,
Byron



How flip that the audience laughed... (0.00 / 0)
...when the President mentioned that Melanie asked to be buried in an Obama t-shirt. Lest we forget he sets the tone in the room during his speeches, there shouldn't have been a dry eye in the house. Instead throughout the press release we hear tired rhetoric and a banal reference to an unsung woman activist from the midwest who lost a valiant struggle for life; the 'bad guys' responsible.

Please don't let the cult of celebrity cloud your thinking into believing that because an unsung activist from hometown America pinged his radar, he will double his resolve on this issue. A bushelful of nothing is still nothing. What we are witness to here is the pinnacle of political theater.

Before you roll your eyes and think to yourself, 'There Rebecca goes again, she can't seem to say anything positive about the President moving healthcare forward, however incrementally." Stop for a moment:

Can you imagine if Obama went on a townhall tour and in each city interviewed families who have lost loved ones due to our broken and inhumane health care system?

Yes I Can! However that would take leadership--a command of the stuation that President Obama has yet to show, a smart strategy to affect positive, lasting change. Such tragic loss of life has repeated itself over and over again since he took office over a year ago. Obama campaigned on HOPE, and poor Melanie died for it. That is all President Obama was (and is) willing to offer the American People.

Our very own Senator McCaskill didn't even wait for the ink to dry on the AP print-out that read of Scott Brown's win in Massachuseets to throw in the towel. Relieved that she had fortuitouly been handed a politically defensible excuse on a silver platter to 'go back to the drawing board,' and the timing couldn't have been better.

May all the Melanie's of America rest in peace.

I am not being flip here as I ask for you to reach out to Senator McCaskill to see if she would deliver a few words at Melanie's memorial service next week. Maybe, just maybe, she will have an epiphany that day and come to realize that she is responsible for doing right by the people of Missouri, and if she has a conscience that operates in concordance with her Democratic constituent's views, this experience may provide the political capital she needs to get on the right side of this issue once and for all--and to make her case with aplomb and conviction.


[ Parent ]
I just called Claire's St. Louis office. (0.00 / 0)
The young man I spoke to said that McCaskill is being made aware of Melanie's memorial service. He said they should know by next Monday or Tuesday whether she will attend and he will call me.

I asked whether McCaskill supports passing health care reform through budget reconciliation. He said she supports passing reform but not through reconciliation. So the man I spoke to in the D.C. office a week ago who said she was still thinking over whether to support the reconciliation route apparently was ill informed.


[ Parent ]
why Claire? (0.00 / 0)
Personally, I don't want to see Claire McCaskill at an event when we are celebrating the life of a true progressive.  Clair will get all the attention, and she doesn't deserve one minute of our time or respect.  

Melanie wished to steward a future.... (0.00 / 0)
...where everyone has access to care. I understand your anger and your reticence. My suggestion to having McCaskill at the service is so that she can see the direct consequence her inaction has wrought. The sobering truth may be an eye-opener for her. Her "let them eat eat cake" attitude of legislating on this issue needs to be stopped.  

McCaskill is ill informed about much, for better or worse she is our representative in Washington. With her seated, our only hope is to change the way inwhich she governs, engaging her meaningfully offers us the chance that she will come to represent our needs in Washington for the better.

We will be honoring Melanie's life if we bring her vision of how it should be lived to fruition. What better place than at a gathering that celebrates the blessings of the person that she was?


[ Parent ]
Claire's chances of seeing the light. (0.00 / 0)
"The sobering truth may be an eye-opener for her."  Seriously?

Rebecca, I admire your optimism about a career politician seeing anything other than her own future prosperity.


[ Parent ]
Caeer politicians and social change... (0.00 / 0)
...career politicians voted in the Security Security Act in 1935 when they saw that poverty among the elderly had skyrocketed to over 50% during the Depression. Subsequently over several administrations Soc. Sec. has been amended to include disability insurance and Medicare, all on many a 'career politician's' watch.

Sarah Jo, did you vote for Claire McCaskill?

How about all of the other dyed-in-the-wool progressives who did?

Most were settling for the lesser of two evils while in the voting booth, granted, but what choice do we have but to engage her?

Polticians are driven by one thing--public opinion, because in their steeplechase for votes, it is the pressure of public opinion that forces them to act, (mostly to react) upon the desires of their constituency.

You seem be to mistaking my 'optimism' for naivete.

McCaskill is a tool to be worked with in our need to fix a very broken machine, no more no less.  

 


[ Parent ]
About
Read before posting:

Getting Started

Posting Guidelines

Diary Formatting Tips

Congressional Contact Info

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


SMP on Facebook
Show Me Progress on Facebook

Other State Blogs
News & Announcements

Powered by: SoapBlox